***
Hari Darshan |
Myrrh |
***
Hari Darshan |
Myrrh |
A Cycle Brand masala incense picked up from my local incense shop. This is a fairly crude masala - there is sandalwood here, but it's not creamy and sweet, it's quite rough and earthy and dark. There is an appeal here, but quite a basic one - like a cuppa with spotted dick at Joe's Caff compared to cream tea at the Ritz. Both have their charms, but in a different way.
The stick itself is quite rough. A paste made from fragrant ingredients, binder, charcoal dust, and water has been hand rolled onto a plain bamboo splint, and then rolled in a finishing powder to prevent the wet paste from sticking to other finished sticks. The paste has dried hard. The appearance is what you might expect if you shoved a stick up the arse of someone with diarrhoea. The stick itself feels rough and bumpy. It's not promising. The scent on the stick is OK. Not great, but OK. It is quite flowery - the scent propelled by a fragrance oil or perfume.
On the burn the scent is woody and earthy. The tones are dark and heavy, and the flowery fragrance that was on the stick doesn't really show up here. I have found it is often the case that lighter fragrances (such as fruits and florals) can get swamped by heavy ones (such as musks and woods), and that oil or perfume scents are often lovely on the stick, but can burn off quickly, so are sometimes unable to make themselves noticed against the organic material which burn more slowly.
Overall I'm not impressed with this incense, though it is sturdy and workmanlike, and I have a modest liking for it. It's not a good sandalwood, but the general spicy wood aroma is cleansing and reassuring.
Date: March 2022 Score: 24
Though there is an appearance of this being a masala incense, it smells and behaves like a perfumed incense. There is a sharp volatility to the scent on the stick, with that petrol/alcohol tang you get with perfumed products such as car air-fresheners, disinfectant, etc. It's not an unpleasant scent - far from it: it has a solid sandalwood scent. But it is not pure. It is not magic. It is not natural.
Date: Jan 2023 Score: 24
Ranga Rao |
Sandalwood |
Second review - scroll down for earlier review |
First review |
One of a bunch of incense grabbed at The Loft Ladder in The Marlands shopping arcade in Southampton, Southern England. A groovy shop which also sells old vinyl records and some cool t-shirts. This is a wood paste machine-extruded lower priced everyday perfumed incense from Balaji, who also sell dhoop and masala incense.
It's a reasonably pleasant scent - modest, light, clean, modern. The blurb on the bottom of the box says: Brings Divine Fantasia Fragrance", a Google search for which brings me to Anna Sui Fantasia, a perfume created in 2017 which is sold in a delightful bottle topped with a prancing unicorn. The scent description of Fantasia is remarkably similar to this Balaji Gem, which is lightly floral, jasmine and rose, with gentle citrus top notes, some raspberry middles notes, and the merest touch of cedarwood at the base.
Date: March 2022 Score: 26
Balaji Agarbatti Company |
Best rose incense |
Even though I have been doing this blog for 10 years (woohoo, ten years - I missed the anniversary date in Feb, and only just noticed that it's been ten years), and have burned some incense in that time, mostly Indian, I feel I'm only now starting to get some understanding of the Indian incense market. The bulk of the market is this incense - everyday perfumed incense. Not expensive, but well made, and producing pleasant, consistent, and reliable scents. These 8 inch sticks, with approx 6 1/2 inches of extruded charcoal paste impregnated with a synthetic perfume, are standard fare, and are sold in an oblong cardboard packet with 20g of sticks for 10 Rupees (around 10p). The sticks light up with a black smoke, then settle into a modest burn for around 50 minutes.
The top companies, such as Cycle, Moksh, Mangaldeep, Zed Black, HEM, Patanjali, Hari Darshan, and Nandi, succeed domestically through producing reliable, professional sticks with attractive, commercial scents at a low cost, and with good marketing and distribution. Some, such as HEM, will also succeed in exports, aiming, as with the domestic market, at an audience who are mainly looking for pleasant, everyday scents at a low cost. There are some customers who are willing to pay more for incense with scents that are less synthetic and more natural, and which are, or give the appearance of being, masala incense, and this is a growing market, which has for years been mostly dominated by Satya. Some customers look for something other than or "beyond" Satya, feeling that Satya is too "big business" or commonplace for them to identify with (and image is key in all products); so there are small, traditional companies, "artisan" or "cottage", who don't, perhaps, have the will, the desire, or the means to go into large production, and so remain small and traditional. They may wish to remain traditional, hand-rolling with as close to natural products as they can because that is their ethos and way of life, or they may feel a little trapped in the marketplace, unable to expand into synthetic and/or larger scale production without losing their existing customer base. These small, traditional producers may hope to develop a name for themselves, though many find it more economic to sell their incense in bulk to own brand or resellers, such as Happy Hari, Absolute Bliss, Prabhuji's Gifts, or Berk.
In and around these incense makers, are the hundreds, perhaps thousands, of incense companies, mostly small, but many medium sized, who aim for one or more of the existing markets - either directly under their own name, selling in their own branded packets, or in bulk stick order to a distributor, who may themselves be quite small, or may be quite large, such as Mangaldeep.
Anyway, enough waffle....
These sticks are quite mild and gently informative. The scent doesn't have a big impact, and doesn't remain for long, but there is no unpleasant ashy after-smell. They are what they are. An inexpensive everyday modest room freshener. Light up a handful and wander round the house doing a low key, low cost, synthetic smudging. Because they are so modest, best grab something more assertive if the dog has just farted.
Date: Oct 2023 Score: 22
Patanjali Agarbatti - a branch of Patanjali Ayurved, a manufacturer and distributor of various foods and goods in India, who were founded in 1956 in New Delhi, are considered one of the Top Incense Brands in India, so I'm trying them out. AyurvedaProducts.co.uk sell Pantanjali incense for a modest price - 20g boxes for £1.49, which retail in India for 10 Rupees (10p or 13 US cents). The sticks are machine-extruded charcoal paste on a machine-cut bamboo splint, impregnated with a perfume. This is standard perfumed incense, the most popular form of incense in India. It can be used to freshen a room, to cover a bad smell, to create a mood, to keep away flies, or to be used as part of a pooja ritual.
This one is called Pooja, though it has no special characteristics to differentiate it from any standard/everyday perfumed incense stick. There are the familiar volatile aromas on the stick, reminiscent of a pine disinfectant. The stick burns evenly, and at a good pace, dispersing the scent into the air so the room becomes informed by the scent, but not overwhelmed. This is not bargain basement shit which simply smells of cheap sawdust and burned ash, but nor is it pleasingly engaging. It is just there - a perfumed incense scent. The scent is not clearly defined - it's a generic perfumed incense smell, though it's in the floral area, inclining toward sweet. It's generally sort of pleasant, though has tones of chemical, and is kinda sharp.
Essentially this is not great, but neither is it obviously offensive. I am a little surprised it is considered a market leader, as this is just above bargain basement stuff. I guess price and ready availability, coupled with it not being offensive, would incline people toward buying it and then repeat buying it. 10 Rupees is a competitive price - though Koya's have some incense at this price, which is more characterful and pleasant than this dull stuff.
I came upon a series of Top 10 lists of top Indian incense companies, and made a post about them: Top Incense Brands in India. One of the companies that figures fairly high on most lists is Patanjali Agarbatti - a branch of Patanjali Ayurved, a manufacturer and distributor of various foods and goods in India, who were founded in 1956 in New Delhi. I had not heard of them before. I sought out some of their incense and found a UK supplier: AyurvedaProducts.co.uk who sells them for a modest price - this 20g/16 stick Tathastu box was £1.49. It retails in India for 10 Rupees (10p or 13 US cents). The sticks are machine-extruded charcoal paste on a machine-cut bamboo splint, impregnated with a perfume. This is standard perfumed incense, the most popular form of incense in India. It can be used to freshen a room, to cover a bad smell, to create a mood, to keep away flies, or to be used as part of a pooja ritual.
Tathastu, according to Google translate, means "so be it". Hmm. It must be a popular expression because there was a Hindi-language film made with that title in 2006. Oh well, so be it...
There are petrol tones on the stick, but the scent is pleasant, if a little hard to pin down. Sandalwood, prune, wool, jasmine, leather.... various notes, but nothing really specific. It's kind of cool - mostly neutral, modest, pleasant, inoffensive, meh. It's OK - not something worth spending time over. It's an OK everyday perfumed incense.
Patanjali Agarbatti |
A standard everyday perfumed cone from Hari Darshan, part of a box of 12 different fragrances from Amazon for £14. They're a decent size and burn slowly and consistently. The aroma on the cone is musky and woody, which works for me. The scent on the cone is brighter and more attractive than on the burn. It's a little cheap and smoky on the burn initially, though the woody musk does come through, especially once the burn reaches the fatter parts of the cone.
Hari Darshan |
Sandalwood |
Two stick sample from Padma Store in Germany - the name roughly means scented light or incense stick. The paper bag has had to be wrapped in cling film - presumably because it was absorbing so much of the fragrant oils that had been used in the stick.
I like this incense. It's rich and fragrant, with a sweet, heady floral bouquet. Quite fresh with notes of rose and gardenia - creamy, zesty, little touches of spice to keep the interest and stop it becoming cloying. The stick has a dry, crumbly charcoal paste hand-rolled quite well onto a roughly cut bamboo splint dyed pink, and then finished with a wood powder (melnoorva). It smells very Indian - Indian incense. A sort of typical, ah, yes, that's Indian incense. And there's some prickly warm wool there as well, so a bit of halmaddi. The scent is mainly floral.
I was unsure about the name, as I have seen it written various ways, Shroff, Channabasappa, Shroff Channabasappa & Sons, Channabasappa Company, etc. I looked into it, and it appeared to me that the family had diverged, with one side (Shroff) dealing with the incense making and the other side (Channabasappa) dealing with the retail, so I asked, and Prathik Shroff confirmed: "To your question, yes, it’s two sides of the same coin. Channabasappa & Co is our official trade name and Shroff is our family name and we decided to keep that name as we have for the past 100 years or more." The family have their shop on Avenue Road in Bangalore - this is a busy retail street with numerous other incense families making and/or selling incense as they have done for around a hundred years.
The company was founded in 1882 by Shroff Channabasappa. They sold incense to the Maharaja of Mysore (Mysore was the original name of the state of Karnataka), and they had a stand at the 1930 British Industries Fair in Olympia. In 1949 they were one of the founding members of the All India Agarbathi Manufacturers’ Association, along with other leading Mysore/Karnataka incense companies. Mysore is the region where incense with a bamboo stick was first developed, and the Mysore manufacturers T.l Updhayay and Attar Khasim Sahib had displayed this idea at the British Empire Exhibition in 1924, so the Shroff Channabasappa family were well placed in the region that was at the heart of the early development of modern Indian incense.
The Shroff family stand at the 1930 British Industries Fair in Olympia |
***
Shroff Incense |
Second review - scroll down for earlier |
First review |
It's been a long time since I reviewed any HEM perfumed incense. HEM are not my favourite incense company, but they are cheap, decently made (you always get the scent of the perfume), and can sometimes surprise with a delightful scent, such as their Frankincense-Myrrh, which I rate higher than their masala incense. I was tempted by this Amazon offer of 22 packs for £10, and got it. This is the sort of casual incense that we use around the house to brighten up the place, or cover up stale or bad smells. We don't generally use HEM to sit and enjoy the scents, though sometimes a scent just hits the spot.
This is not really one that hits the spot. It has a generic "perfumed incense" smell with petrol tones to the fore initially, and all through the burn there is a sense more of fabric conditioner than incense. However, it is not unpleasant. It is floral, with notes of rose, some lemon, some berry fruits. It's OK. Not offensive. Not great. It's kinda clean and bright and fresh. The package came straight from India by air, so the perfume in this, and the other 21, will be fresh - which is important with perfumed incense as the perfume can and does evaporate over time.
The sticks are machine made, and the burn is consistent, lasts a long time, and fills the room with perfume without being smoky, over-bearing, or irritating. As a room freshener, for around 50p for 20 sticks, it's OK. Cheap and cheerful, a little utilitarian, but does the job if your needs are modest.
Date: March 2022 Score: 24
This is the fifth of the seven single stick samples of Prabhuji's Gifts Chakra series of masala incense. Prabhuji's Gifts are a spiritual American based company who commission their incense from India. The sales of the incense are used to finance their mission to spread the teaching of their founder, the Chilean born mystic, Prabhuji. So far I have found the sticks to be modestly pleasant, especially on the stick, less pleasant on the burn, and leaning toward dry, woody, earthy, and plant-like, though with occasional moments of pleasurable and interesting scents. I was more engaged with the first scent I tried in the series, the Muladhara, though whether this was because it is genuinely more appealing, because I spent more time on it and discovered more, or because I was simply being more generous I don't know. I note the oil marks on the packet of this one, and those are of essential oil - which certainly makes the packet smell nice - distinctly floral and sweet and soapy. I don't know yet what scents are in this stick, as my samples don't say - the only info I have is: Sacral Chakra Swadhisthana. I'll look up for more information after I have started the review.
All the sticks in the series have been made the same way - a fragrant masala charcoal paste has been hand rolled onto a usually hand cut bamboo splint dyed pink. The differences have been in the dryness of the paste. This one is damp. It is also a little fatter than the others. The scent on the stick is richer than the others, though less rich than the scent on the packet. I suspect a lot of the essential oil fragrance has been absorbed by the paper packet. I guess this is why a lot of incense distributors use plastic sleeves instead of the the more planet friendly paper ones. There is a faint note of parma violets, some rose, soap, lemongrass, and underneath, just a bit of wood, sandalwood.
As with the other samples, the scent on the burn is dry, spicy, woody, with little sense of the aroma on the stick. I was patient with the first stick, the Muladhara, and burned it in several sessions over two or three days. It was my first experience with this company, Prabhuji's Gifts; I knew nothing about them except what I learned as I burned that first stick - that they are a spiritual company reselling/commissioning Indian incense in order to fund their project; so I had no idea what they would be like. I have been less patient as I have gone though the rest of the range, as I feel I am getting a handle on these sticks now, and I am not that impressed. They are OK, but they are not for me - the quality is not here. The best part of the aroma is conveyed by essential oils which are not fully integrated into the paste, so are barely noticeable during the burn. I don't know if the "artisans in India’s cottage industry" who make this Chakra range make other incense for Prabhuji's Gifts, but as it stands I'm not encouraged to seek out more of Prabhuji's Gifts branded incense if they are anything like this.
I've looked up the details, and this is Sensuality & Creativity, which contains vanilla, rose, and vetiver.
The customer reviews on the sales page of the Chakra range are very enthusiastic five stars.
Date: March 2022 Score: 23
Fourth of the single stick samples from Padma Store in Germany of Prabhuji's Gifts masala incense in their Chakra range. I liked the first sample, and enjoyed the scents on the stick of the others, but felt that those scents did not come through on the burn. All the stick appear to be made the same way: a fragrant charcoal paste has been hand rolled onto a bamboo splint, either hand cut or, as here, machine cut, and then dyed pink. A pleasantly fragrant finishing powder has been rolled onto the wet paste to prevent the sticks from clinging together. The consistency of the paste varies from moist and crumbly, though soft and crumbly to this which is fairly rock hard. The amount of paste on each stick is fairly modest. Each stick has a pleasant fragrance suggestive of essential oils and/or perfume. The scent on this stick is, as with the others, modestly pleasant and promising. It has a creamy sandalwood and floral tone, with some mild hints of halmaddi - a floral halmaddi.
As with the others, the scent on the burn is less delightful than the scent on the stick. None of the burn scents are unpleasant as such, simply a little crude compared to the stick scents, and fairly dry, spicy, and prickly - akin to the earthy plant based incenses of Tibet. Dry incenses are not among my favourites. This does have some OK woody notes, though it remains fairly simplistic, and doesn't take me anywhere.
On looking up details on this, I find that the name is Communication & Wisdom, and the scents are Oriental Woods and Amber. I'm certainly getting the wood, and - yes - the amber, now my attention has been drawn to it. There are moments of sweeter warmth with a sense of herbs and hedges. Mild, but giving the whole a little more interest. I'm liking this a little more than I was anticipating after the previous two in this Chakra series.
Date: March 2022 Score: 24
This is my third Prabhuji's Gifts incense - all are in their Chakra range. Prabhuji's Gifts are an American based spiritual company who commission their incense from India. The sales of the incense are used to finance their mission to spread the teaching of their founder, the Chilean born mystic, Prabhuji. The first sample I found to be pleasant, the second I found to be quite weak, so I am curious as to how this one will go.
The stick is a soft, moist, crumbly, fragrant charcoal hand rolled onto a hand cut bamboo splint dyed pink, then rolled in a finishing powder. The scent on the stick is quite heady with a balance between floral and musk, and some warm woolly notes of halmaddi. It's nice, and quite promising.
The scent on the burn is mildly pleasant, though doesn't quite live up to the promise on the stick. It's a little acidic and dry, almost harsh, with more plant like notes than aesthetically pleasing scents. Burning grass and cow dung come to mind, with some peppery sprinkles. Little of the floral and musk tones from the stick are really coming through. This does present more as low end masala incense than the more refined promise of the scent on the stick. I suspect that the scent on the stick is produced with modest doses of oils or perfumes, which evaporate quickly during the burn, leaving us with the baser, heavier notes of the plant material, which only come to life during the burn.
I've now looked up images of the packet (I got my sample from Padma Store, who sent me single sticks with minimal information) - and I now see the full name (Love & Sensitivity), and the intended scents: patchouli, geranium, and rose. Well, floral and musky tones are present on the stick, which matches with the intended scents, though cruder, heavier, ill-defined plant-like scents dominate in the burn. I like the scent on the stick, though I'm not at all keen on the scent on the burn.
Date: March 2022 Score: 21
I've stumbled upon one of those list articles that are so popular on the internet - you know "Ten Best ...."; though this one is about incense companies (brands) in India: Top 10 Best Incense Sticks (Agarbatti) Brands In India. There is no criteria by which the Top 10 Best had been selected, though my assumption is that these are (among) the companies achieving highest domestic sales. Of the names on the list I know that Cycle (Ranga Rao), HEM, and Moksh, are among the most popular in India - all of them leading perfumed incense companies (perfumed incense dominates the popular Indian market - masala incense is also popular, though is regarded as premium, and tends to be sold at a premium price point). And while I recognise most of the others, there are some names I don't know, such as Patanjali Agarbatti (some now ordered) and Tataf Agarbatti. Curious about the authenticity and accuracy of this list of the "Top10 Best", I searched for similar lists, and found a few more. Most had the obvious names, and the order is largely the same in each list, with differences at the bottom of each list with a changing array of other companies, while some had no known incense companies - just a list of unknown companies, so appeared to be purely promotional, with no research having been conducted.
I thought it might be interesting to gather these lists together:
The top companies, such as Cycle, Moksh, Mangaldeep, Zed Black, HEM, Patanjali, Hari Darshan, and Nandi, succeed domestically through producing reliable, professional sticks with attractive, commercial scents at a low cost, and with good marketing and distribution. Some, such as HEM, will also succeed in exports, aiming, as with the domestic market, at an audience who are mainly looking for pleasant, everyday scents at a low cost. There are some customers who are willing to pay more for incense with scents that are less synthetic and more natural, and which are, or give the appearance of being, masala incense, and this is a growing market, which has for years been mostly dominated by Satya. Some customers look for something other than or "beyond" Satya, feeling that Satya is too "big business" or commonplace for them to identify with (and image is key in all products); so there are small, traditional companies, "artisan" or "cottage", who don't, perhaps, have the will, the desire, or the means to go into large production, and so remain small and traditional. They may wish to remain traditional, hand-rolling with as close to natural products as they can because that is their ethos and way of life, or they may feel a little trapped in the marketplace, unable to expand into synthetic and/or larger scale production without losing their existing customer base. These small, traditional producers may hope to develop a name for themselves, though many find it more economic to sell their incense in bulk to own brand or resellers, such as Happy Hari, Absolute Bliss, Prabhuji's Gifts, or Berk.
In and around these incense makers, are the hundreds, perhaps thousands, of incense companies, mostly small, but many medium sized, who aim for one or more of the existing markets - either directly under their own name, selling in their own branded packets, or in bulk stick order to a distributor, who may themselves be quite small, or may be quite large, such as Mangaldeep.
Top 10 Best Incense Sticks (Agarbatti) Brands In India |
13 Best Agarbatti Brands in India |
Agarbatti Manufacturers in India [Top 10 Manufacturers] |