 |
| Second review (Feb 2026) - scroll down for earlier |
These are the same sticks I reviewed back in May 2022. The cold throw scent on the stick was quite vivid with spice and wood. The hot throw scent on the burn was smoky and prickly and plain. I felt that it might be old stock - it is not showing on the company's
current (2026) catalogue, and when
ORS reviewed it in 2011 they said it had been discontinued. This has turned up on my desk, and I note it is
still for sale on Ephra World. I have found that true traditional masala where the fragrant ingredients are mixed within the paste will retain its fragrance for many years, especially if the paste is wood based. Incense where the fragrant ingredients are applied as liquid to the outside of the stick, doesn't last as long because the scents will gradually evaporate. These sticks are strongly fragranced on the outside (though may also have some fragrance ingredients within the paste), so if they have been discontinued since 2011 then I can well understand if the scent has degraded over the years. Why Ephra World still has stocks is curious - perhaps its a stick that doesn't sell much. From my experience in 2022 I wouldn't be keen to buy again, but everyone's tastes are different. I sometimes find myself rowing against the stream.
Scent on the stick is buttery, but with a whiff of the rancid about it. Hmm. I've looked into the possibilities for this, and the most likely is that butyric acid has formed due to either a breakdown of one of the fragrance oils, or a contamination of the binder material. Beyond the fatty vomit smell, there is some sense of violets. And the further I am away from the stick the less I notice the vomit, and the more I notice the violets and some creamy sandalwood.
The scent on the burn is mildly spicy and woody with pencil shavings - cedar, juniper, with creamy sandalwood notes, and the violet comes in along with sweet touches of vanilla. Hmmm. I'm liking this. The experience today is very different to that four years ago. Today I'm not at all liking the cold throw scent, while I am (mildly) enjoying the hot throw scent. Yeah, the more I burn this, the more I like it. Which has surprised me. I'm moving this up considerably, and putting the box in my review again pile so I can see how I feel about it again in year or two's time.
Date: Feb 2026 Score: 30/50
 |
| First review (May 2022) |
The sticks are fragrant masala charcoal paste hand rolled onto pink bamboo splints, and then covered in a fragrant melnoorva powder the main purpose of which originally was to stop the sticks from gluing together when drying. The charcoal paste is dry and crumbly, possibly indicating low levels of fragrant or essential oils. There is a mighty fragrance on the stick, quite spicy and woody, moderately volatile, and very likeable.
Its not so attractive on the burn. Indeed, it's not attractive at all. Quite smoky and prickly and fairly plain - just like burning a piece of wood. I quite like woody, but this is dry and dull, and doesn't develop or do much. Burn a bit of rolled up newspaper and you'd get a similar sort of one dimensional scent. One aspect I do like is that it doesn't leave much ash.
For me this is low end masala. I got this from my local hippy shop in Southampton. It's possible it is old stock of perfumed masala, and the fragrance has evaporated as it does with other perfumed incense over time, so leaving just the dried paste ingredients, so what we've got left is a bit of halmaddi, and some dried plants and woods - binders and fixatives. Whatever, not impressed. They are available online in Europe (
15 sticks for just under 2 Euros) and USA (
8gm for £1). If you like basic Tibetan dried plant-life incense, then you might like this. Otherwise, likely not - unless you find a fresh one with the perfume still active.
Date: May 2022 Score: 18/50
***