The Incense Hunter

Photos used in reviews are taken by me, sometimes supported by promotional photos. Some illustrative images on general pages may be AI-generated or AI-assisted.

Wednesday, 26 February 2025

Loose and home-made incense

 


I'm gathering here all the loose and/or home-made incense reviews I have done. These are small operations who sell or gift their hand made incense via friends or Etsy or Facebook or forums or word of mouth. I find a direct connection between this form of incense and the original incenses made for thousands of years. Often these makers will research into ancient ways of making incense and share that research and their recipes with each other. When they sell they may charge mostly to cover costs rather than to make a profit. These are generally non-commercial operations. And they can be the most interesting and authentic incenses available. 


Reviews

* = Review over 5 years old so may not be reliable


SamsaSpoon
Homemade Swiss Stone Pine
 (D)
Oct 2023 - Score: 50↑ 


SamsaSpoon
Homemade Indian Frankincense & Cardamom
 (D)
April 2023 - Score: 42 
  

Underworld Apothecary Djinn Incense (L)
Dec 2020 - Score: 38 
   

    
Feb 2025 - Score: 31


SamsaSpoon Homemade Nerikoh Night Leaves 
Feb 2025 - Score: 30
  
   
SamsaSpoon Homemade "Dragon" 
Feb 2025 - Score: 26  


Kemet Design Bast Incense (L)
Sept 2025 - Score:  21


Kemet Design Hathor Incense (L)
July 2017 - Score: 19*
 

Kemet Design Kyphi Incense (L)
July 2017 - Score: 18* 
   


Reviews: 9
Top score: 50
Bottom score: 18
Average: 

Conclusion: I thought I'd reviewed more than this. I know I've burned more than this. This is an interesting area of incense, and one I want to explore a bit more. 

***

 

Tuesday, 25 February 2025

SamsaSpoon Homemade Nerikoh Night Leaves

 


A gift from Irene of Rauchfahne, who as well as running her incense blog, also makes her own incense. Hers is not a commercial operation. She makes incense for herself and friends. After she sent me her Swiss Stone Pine, which I adored, I asked her to send me some more, and insisted on paying for it. I also asked if I could say that she would make incense on request for people. She was pleased to get an order from India. But, as she is an admin on the Reddit incense forum, there was a bit of a nonsense from one member of that forum, about a conflict of interest. I know this hurt and embarrassed her. She is the most ethical person I have encountered. 

I have just bought an adjustable electric incense burner from AliExpress, and I thought this would be a good opportunity to try it out. It was slow warming up, and as it was new to me, I also set up my NKlaus tealight candle incense burner, which I am familiar with. With both burners the incense takes a LONG time coming to life. 

Irene says that the incense is based on a little known traditional Japanese incense called Nerikoh, which means "kneaded incense". My understanding is that this was a form of Japanese medicine. Frankincense, as I have been learning, has proven medicinal properties,  which may also have some benefit for people with certain cancers. These nerikoh incense balls contain small amounts of frankincense wrapped in fruits and/or honey, and were a means for people to consume frankincense as a medicine or  palliative. Irene (SamsaSpoon) talks about nerikoh, including the recipe, on Reddit, here and here

A ball of Nerikoh Night Leaves has been in my electric burner and tealight heater at top heat for over an hour. There is no smoke, and little scent. What scent I am getting is mostly the prune. I have now lowered the incense so the flame of the candle is touching it. There is a gentle scent of frankincense merged with the prune. Quite pleasant. From the electric burner I'm simply getting scorched prune. I have chopped the ball into very small pieces to allow the frankincense to be heated quicker, and now I'm getting some smoke and some fragrance. I have done the same with the ball on the tealight burner, and also getting a positive result. This does seem to be the way forward. 

Of the two scents, the one from my tealight is the one I prefer. The scent from the electric burner smells muddled, hot, poorly defined, oddly waxy. The one from the tealight smells pure and pleasant. 

I am fascinated by this incense. There's a mature wine aroma combined with soft resin. I find it a pleasant, soft, fruity scent, but it's the story behind this nerikoh type incense that has mostly caught my attention. As part of the process, the fruit based paste or dough containing the fragrant ingredients is buried for a period of time (three years according to Susanne Fischer in The Complete Incense Book) in order to ferment. There is a distinct fermented aspect to the aroma of the pellet as it is warmed. Though Fischer talks about Nerikoh in relation to the fragrant pellets used in Koh-do, the ceremony or game of "the way of incense", she does make mention of the production process being similar to  "popular medicine", and this is what I've read elsewhere. It kind of makes more sense for it to be a medicine to be eaten rather than an incense to be burned. Though it could be used for both. 

I am delighted and intrigued by this incense, and Irene has again amazed me by what she has sent. Though as an incense to be burned for its fragrance, I wasn't that impressed. It took a long time to get at the scent - though I think I have learned that it is best to break the pellet into very small pieces and inflict on it as high a heat as possible, and that the candle flame works better than the electric burner, even on top setting. However, even when the scent was broken open, I liked it rather than was inspired or lifted by it.  


Date: Feb 2025   Score: 30 
***


Haria Rose Dhoop Sticks

 


I've not been particularly impressed with Haria's dhoops. To me, they are not traditional dhoops - they are more like perfume-dipped cones than natural dhoops. However, I have found them quite acceptable, and even quite decent. They are pleasantly smoky. Firm, but not aggressive. And they produce an attractive and cleansing scent, albeit not special or heavenly. 

The scent on the stick is sharp and floral. The fragrance oil may be natural or synthetic, but, whatever the origin, it appears to have been blended with a solvent such as DPG or DEP, to strengthen and prolong the fragrance, and also to make it go further, and so reduce the cost. 

It burns well, releasing an attractive column of grey smoke. The scent is decent and attractive, and is clearly rose. But it doesn't do much more than signal "rose". I like it. I think it is well made at a price. It's not offensive. It cleans and lifts a room. As a floral smudge or room freshener, this is OK. But it doesn't do more than that. Essentially this is the same quality as the Loban I've just reviewed, but I personally liked the Loban a bit more, so gave it a higher score. Some people, I know, get puzzled that I score by how much I enjoy an incense rather than by some abstract technical "incense judge" score. But there you go. Each to their own. You can give technical points to your life partner, or you can just fall in love.  


Date: Feb 2025   Score: 26
***


Dhoop


Haria Loban dhoop

 


Yesterday I got an email from someone working for Haria, and today, while rummaging in the boxes in my room still trying to sort out my backlog, I came upon some Haria dhoops I hadn't reviewed. That must be a sign!  I've only reviewed a few incenses from Haria. They've all been dhoops, and they were acceptable, but didn't really make an impression. And I've not reviewed that much loban (also called sambrani), though on the whole I have been inclined to like the loban I've burned. While loban is regarded in the West as the Indian term for benzoin, or any tree resin, in reality loban is usually a resin mix involving benzoin and other gums and resins.

This is a very enjoyable loban. The sticks are short, dry, firm. Quite tidy. There is a sharp note on the stick - not unpleasant, though suggestive of a fragrance oil being blended with a chemical such as DEP or DPG. My assumption is that these aren't natural dhoops where the fragrance has been folded into the paste, but are dipped dhoops. Much like dipped cones. My assumption is that the paste is extruded, cut into three inch pieces, dried, and then immersed in a fragrance solution. It's quick, easy, and cost effective. Pure fragrant oil can be purchased for around £10 a litre, and then blended with DEP/Agarbatti oil at around £1 per litre - the proportions will vary, but are likely to start at 5 parts DEP to 1 part fragrance oil in a process described here. Beyond the sharp notes on the stick, there are jammy and floral notes. There is more of a signature of jasmine than of loban. I am classing this as a perfumed incense rather than natural dhoop. 

The scent on burning is clean, fragrant, fruity, sweet, resinous. There is an abundance of smoke, which is attractive, and there is a smoky element to the scent, which is part of the overall experience, though I waver to and fro on how much I like that. It's a reasonably pleasant element to the fragrance - it is dry, chalky, mineral - a clean, and somewhat vibrant smoke, though it can linger a little in an ashy way. Not unpleasant, but heading that way. On the whole I like this. It's a cleansing and pleasant experience. Not complex or heavenly, but on the whole a good experience. Useful for smudging the house.  


Date: Feb 2025   Score: 30
***


Dhoop


Monday, 24 February 2025

Variety Packs (3-in-1, etc)

 



Variety packs, often called 3-in-1 or similar, are popular in the budget end of the incense world. They tend to be single packs with three or more different scents inside. They are different to gift packs, which tend to gather together usually five different, though related, packs of incense, into one package, such as Impressions Gift Pack and Hari Darshan Hindu Gods Gift Pack. They are also different to sample packs, where a company will gather together several samples of their products in order to encourage consumers to buy the individual products, such as Shoyeido Magnifiscents Sampler. A variety pack is generally intended to be an end in itself - it is the variety that the customer wants, and they will repeat buy. We used to buy such a variety pack - a green box of seven scents, called 105 sticks. We were quite happy with that green box. Then one day our local shop were out of stock, and they recommended Satya Nag Champa as a replacement, and my life changed!  But, yes, the point is that companies will make a variety pack for customers who just want to casually buy one pack of incense a week or month, and like to have a variety of scents. Such people, like we were, are largely buying on price or perceived value. And commonly such variety packs are confined to the budget end of the market, so will generally be perfumed-charcoal, as that is cheap and easy to make, and the scents will be augmented with a chemical such as DEP to help keep the costs down. 

Reviews

* = Review over 5 years old so may not be reliable


Sital 3 in 1 Masala
Jan 2024 - Score: 36 
 

Veer Special 3 in 1 (P)
Apr 2020 - Score: 29*


Dr. Jieer Incense Cone 6 Color (P)
Oct 2022 - Score: 22
   

SHHT GmbH Incense Cones (P)
Oct 2022 - Score: 22
    

ITC Mangaldeep Treya Power of 3-in-1 (P)
Oct 2023 - Score: 21 



Metromilan +7 (P)
Feb 2025 - Score: 21


Ancient Wisdom Loose Assorted (P)
Dec 2023 - Score: 21
   

Windhorse Mixed Sticks (P)
June 2014 - Score: 21
  

Aargee Ayurveda Variety Pack (P)
Feb 2017 - Score: 20*
  

PMS International Assorted Aromas (P)
Jun 2014 - Score: 20*
    

Aanchal Agarbatti 3 in 1 (P)
Apr 2023 - Score: 20
   

Sky Aromatherapy Variety Pack No. 1 (P)
Feb 2026 - Score: 19

  
Sky Aromatherapy Variety Pack No. 2 (P)
Mar 2017 - Score: 11*
  

Reviews:  13
Top Score: 36
Bottom score: 11 
Average: 22

Conclusion: With the exception of Sital 3 in 1 Masala, which are intended to be decent quality, all the variety pack incenses I've had have been bargain basement stuff. I'll be avoiding them in future. 


Metromilan +7

 


I don't know why I have this, nor where it came from. I reviewed four different packs from Metromilan (then known just as Metro) back in 2014, in the early days of IncenseInTheWind, but I wasn't impressed. Cute cat, bright packets, and bold synthetic scents, but not an incense house that held interest for me. I'm not sure why I felt I needed to get another pack - especially one containing seven (yes, count them, seven) different scents. I suspect I was drawn by the name Metromilan because I'm aware that Metro Milan is Metro(milan)'s best known and most successful scent. It looks like the company have decided to name themselves after their best known scent - this does happen. Anyway, here we go. 

There are seven sealed plastic bags inside the pack, each containing six machine-extruded charcoal-dipped sticks. The packets are marked with the fragrance names, and the sticks have different colours. So, the scent called Falah has pink sticks, while the scent called Hadya has green sticks, and so on. I've looked for meanings of the names, and the closest consistent I can find is that they are girl's names. 

Sahar has sandy coloured sticks. The scent on the stick is bright, sharp, heavily synthetic, and is just like a bucket of toilet cleaner fluid. The scent on the burn is sharp, acidic, bright, chemical, mildly offensive. I'm not sure what it is intended to be, but this is a Bri-Nylon shirt in a world that loves natural cotton. The Bri-Nylon structure of the scent is brash and confident - it does have positive qualities, such as its bright, cheerful semi-floral resilience, but like nylon it is cheap and crude, and like nylon catches on my nails and fingers, this catches on my soul. Just about acceptable for keeping away the flies in the outhouse when feeding the cats. [19]

Maheen has natural coloured sticks. Again, a sharp and synthetic note on the stick. This one reasonably deep, but the general impression is of dried old sweat on a nylon shirt. The scent on the burn is somewhat acceptable - it has a scent range, with top, middle, and bottom notes. It's not crude or blunt. Assertive, certainly, but not rude or aggressive. Yeah, it's somewhat seducing me. There's some sexy sweet deep notes along the edge of patchouli, and some playful florals. It's all fairly familiar. I've had this scent before, though can't quite pin it down. It's not a great scent, but it's playful and reasonably attractive. [24]

Zahra has green sticks, a little brighter than the green for the Hadya. Scent on the stick is partly pine disinfectant, and partly an incense scent from my hippy youth. It's cold and sharp, yet has some warm tones that bring me in. It burns attractively, developing on those warm tones, and that familiar hippy incense scent, though is rather smoky and assertive, and gradually becomes too much for my medium sized room. [23]

Haya has purple sticks. As with the others, the scent on the stick is harsh and smells of chemicals rather than perfume. The scent on the burn is fairly obscured. There's some florals, but mostly it's just synthetic room freshener incense. It's not bad bad bad, but it aint good either. It's just an outhouse incense. [20]

Sana has black sticks. Again, the chemical fumes. Plus some vinegar. Quite green and outdoorsy. It's green and a little sharp on the burn. A little vague. A little smoky. A little like jasmine. Smells like bargain basement perfumed-charcoal incense. It's nudging against unpleasant, though not quite there. Certainly it's not an incense I want to burn in the house. [17]

Hadya has a green tip.  The journey with this is the same as the others. A crude chemical note on the stick, with some vague synthetic floral scent. Notes of vinegar and cat piss. I really don't think much care and attention has gone into making these fragrance blends. A splash of this and a splash of that into a big bucket of DEP, and then dip the charcoal blanks into the bucket. Job done. Rinse and repeat. Well, forget the rinse, just repeat. The scent on the burn is a white floral, close to jasmine. I think my main problem with this variety pack is that the scents are mainly focused on white floral, which is not really among my favourite fragrances. And they are garishly synthetic. And there's not a lot to distinguish them from each other, or from any other run of the mill bargain basement perfumed incense. To be fair, this one is not that bad. [22]

Falah has a red tip. It smells of violets and roses in a cold, sharp chemical breeze. It's the most floral, and least chemical of the bunch.  This is an acceptable incense. [23]


So what have I learned from burning this Metromilan variety pack? Well, as regards the Metro(milan) company, I've learned nothing I didn't learn over ten years ago: that they make cheap and crude perfumed-charcoal incense sticks using a lot of a chemical such as DEP to save money. The scents are brash and colourful, rather like the packaging. And I've not yet tried their most acclaimed scent: Metro Milan, which is now called Metromilan. So I've not learned anything - simply confirmed my opinions from 2014 (I have learned so much since then, and my understanding and appreciation of incense has shifted somewhat, but it appears that my response to cheap, brash, and crude is largely the same).  I have reflected, though, on the nature of incense variety packs. These do tend to be aimed at the budget end of the market. There is the appeal that I'm going to get several different scents for roughly the same price as one scent, but it appears to be a false economy as the quality of most of these 3-in-1 or 7in-1 or variety packs is generally not strong. 

Anyway, this +7 has really not been my thing. On the whole I'm usually OK with bright, bold perfumed incense. But Metromilan is just a tad too crude for me. 


Date: Feb 2025   Score: 21 
***

Sunday, 23 February 2025

IBN Saif Trading Frankincense Sticks

 


Sent to me by Irene of the German incense blog Rauchfahne, these are frankincense resin sticks made in Oman (the "land of Frankincense") for or by IBN Saif Trading who trade in Hojari frankincense resin - an acclaimed tree resin gum from the boswellia sacra tree which grows in the Dhofar Mountains. These sticks appear to be the only ones they sell. The stick is rather similar to Jeomra’s Hojari - a stick also made from Hojari resin, though made in Germany by Georg Huber. 

The stick, unlike Jeomra's, is not sprinkled with incense powder, so there is little obvious cool scent. Though, get close, and there's sweet, fruity frankincense, some salad herbs, and a touch of caramel. It reminds me both of Jeomra’s Hojari and of the new resin-smudge sticks coming out of South America. I think incense like this is the future. It's more refreshing, satisfying, and exciting than the increasingly safe and unexciting perfumed-masala Nag Champa clones being exported from India by Wonder Incense and others. 

There's a deal of black smoke when the stick is first lit and is burning. I'm assuming that the black smoke is due to unburned particles because the material is being incompletely consumed by the flames. It's only when the flames are blown out and the material is smouldering with the hot slow burn that the smoke settles into the attractive white blue that many of us enjoy.  The scent is gorgeous. Very much in the style of the resin-smudges from South America. It feels natural and pure. I'm not sure what the combustible material is - I've picked at the dry paste, which is really hard, and I assume it's wood powder. But I'm not getting any smouldering sawdust or burning paper smells, which I generally do with wood powder sticks. I'm wondering if they managed to use just joss powder (tree bark) and a small amount of charcoal. Oh, I just wafted some smoke toward me (not recommended - I do it sometimes to get closer to the scent, but it's actually  healthier, more natural, and generally better to just allow the scent to inform the room. Getting too close to the smoke is kinda like spraying perfume in your face. Not a good idea), and caught a touch of burning wood - a dull fragrance, not uplifting. 

I like this, but, as with Jeomra’s Hojari, I find an opportunity has been lost. There is a bit more going on here than with Jeomra’s Hojari - there's a suggestion of herbs and spices, and there's that dull but clean wood burning scent, but on the whole this is pretty much like burning some resin, except it's on a stick. The resin, though, is damned attractive. Soft, spicy, churchy. Citric touches. Yeah. Nice.  

Cheaper when bought in the original packs

They are available in the original packets of 8 sticks on a number of websites for a reasonable price:  $7; $4; 25 Euros for five packs. Or you can pay a bit more for the "convenience" of buying them from a re-brander - who will take the sticks out of the original packs, and use their own packaging: $18 for 10 sticks; $12 for 12 sticks; $13 for 9 sticks. Or you can order direct from Saif for $2.10.  [Dec 2025: They only do wholesale orders] All costs are without shipping. 


Date: Feb 2025   Score: 36  
***