Incense In The Wind

Burner Burner - Carhartt jacket incense burner

Friday, 28 February 2025

Shoyeido Daily Incense Kyozakura "Kyoto Cherry Blossom"

 


I've not yet explored much Japanese incense; but what I have experienced hasn't encouraged me to explore further. I find Japanese incense to be quite dry and sombre, and with such a mild scent that it is easily overlooked, yet the price is generally quite high. I recently noticed on eBay, some sellers offering samples of Japanese incense, so I got in touch with one of them, and ordered a bunch, which kept the shipping cost low. 

This sample pack was very well packaged by slipping the sticks inside corrugated cardboard. There are five sticks which cost me £1.79, though this has now (as of Feb 2025) increased to £2.58.  Shoyeido are rare among Japanese incense companies in that they do sample packs, though not in the UK - they have to be imported from the US, and even then they only have one stick per fragrance, while this eBay seller provides five sticks. 

     
Kyazakura

This Kyozakura (Kyo is short for Kyoto, the ancient capital of Japan, while zakura is cherry blossom - and Kyoto is famous for its cherry blossom in the spring) is part of a range that Shoyeido call Daily Incense. The Japanese do not consume incense everyday the way that Indians do. It is generally reserved for special occasions, and only used by a small proportion of the population. This makes it difficult for Japanese incense companies to lower costs through scaling up; and so inhibits an expansion of their market. Creating a range for everyday use is good marketing. 

There is a pleasant cherry note in this incense. Along with a scorched plum or raisin. Some faint sandalwood which toys with hinting at burnt paper, but doesn't quite get there. I'm impressed at the strength of the fragrance from such little sticks. Mildly sweet. There's a curious curry, fenugreek or cumin note hovering over it all - both on the stick and in the burn. And I've done a "curry" search in my blog, and found that a curry note is, for me, a fairly common experience with Shoyeido incense. 

The cherry note was fairly short lived, and after that first impact my mind was more focused on other elements - some natural licorice, some bay leaves, and that fenugreek. If I stopped focusing, and let my mind go neutral and wander away, I could pick up sweet cherry, but only at a glance, whereas initially it was more insistent. After the burn is over, there is a mild sense of cherry in the air, but somewhat elusive - the main note in the air is a sort of vague woody pungency.  I liked that moment of cherry at the start, and in general I liked the incense as it burned, but it didn't lift me much, and is not an incense I would reach for.  But it's a fun incense to review. 


Date: Feb 2025  Score: 28
***

"Amber" Frankincense from Yemen

 


I am fascinated by incense resins, especially frankincense. This is one of our oldest, purest, and most acclaimed incenses. I have burned frankincense resin a few times over the 11 years I've had this blog, and I have liked it, but have found it a steep and tricky learning curve, with only slow progress because at no time have I really settled down to concentrate on exactly the best way to burn this extra-ordinary incense. Initially I burned the resin on charcoal discs. A messy, awkward process, but it worked well, and I had moments I recall as being very special. Then after discussion with a few enthusiasts, I was encouraged to get an electric burner. I have tried three static electric burners (two have now broken - it seems the cheap ones are not that sturdy); though I also found using burners awkward and messy, and found it hard to control the heat to get at the optimum temperature, which enthusiasts have assured me  will result in olfactory heaven. Then I moved to an adjustable tealight burner, which I have found more pleasing than the static electric burners, though a little fiddly, and apt to errors. I have now acquired a cheap adjustable electric burner, though still not finding it easy to use, nor that rewarding. Melted resin can be difficult to clean off the burners. Yet using foil to protect the burners can sometimes inhibit the heat so the resin doesn't burn as well as it might (especially as my cheap adjustable burner doesn't go to a very high heat anyway).  However, I will keep experimenting. 

I know only a little bit about frankincense, so over the last couple of days I've been doing a bit of research. I'm finding conflicting and/or incomplete information in various places. Resin sellers can be useful sources of easily digestible info, though may be inclined to favour their own sources, and so not give a complete picture. Some sources may focus a lot on the scientific aspects, while others focus a lot on the political aspects. It's a complex and somewhat huge area which I've only dipped into so far, but will give a quick summary of the main points of what I've gathered so far, with the intention of adding more as I go along. 

Resins are a gum produced by trees, essentially to protect them when cut. The gum will ooze out of the tree to cover the cut, and then harden. This gum may be classed as sap or resin. Resin is similar to sap, but is not the same substance. While all trees produce sap, only trees in the pine family produce resin. The tree from which frankincense comes is not in the pine family, so technically frankincense is not a resin, it is a fragrant sap. Fragrant sap contains the active ingredient α-Pinene, and it is that which is responsible for the fragrance. Saps contain sugar (maple syrup is a sap), so a fragrant sap is sweeter than a resin. 

Frankincense comes from several different trees in the Boswellia family - with each tree producing distinctive resin with its own character. The trees are native to the countries of Oman and Yemen, in the south of the Arabian Peninsula, and to Ethiopia and Somalia, in the Horn of Africa, and has been traded from those countries for thousands of years. Though these days the countries are war torn, and with a recent demand in the West for the healing properties of frankincense, crude harvesting by desperate farmers is threatening the existence of frankincense trees in these countries. In 2012 it was replanted in Israel in the Middle East, 1,500 years after dying out there. Frankincense is also sold as coming from North Africa and India, though most sources agree that the southern Arabian Peninsula and the Horn of Africa are the regions producing the best frankincense, and of those, it seems most folks point to Oman as having the best of the best. 

Incense is graded by size and colour. The lighter the colour, and the larger the size, the more expensive and prized it becomes. With the very pale coloured resin giving a green appearance, and these are often termed "Royal". This Royal green frankincense, also called Hojari, grows in the Dhofar mountains in Oman. The Boswellia tree family in addition to frankincense provides the other classic incenses Myrrh, Copal and Palo Santo

Included in an order of incense from Herbal Dimensions.com was this small sample pack of Amber Frankincense from Yemen. This is regarded as not as pure as the royal or green frankincense, though is more suited to incense burning as it contains more of the fragrance oil content. I burned it on both my new adjustable electric burner (it struggled to get warm enough to allow the resin to really display itself - at least for me as I wanted more aroma), and my adjustable tealight burner (more successful, though it took me a while to find the right height - too low and it singed, too high and there wasn't enough aroma). 

There are pine notes, citric notes, some turps and petrol, and a general sense of "church incense". It's overall very warm, bright, uplifting, and pleasant - reaching into memories and associations. I liked it. 


Date: Feb 2025   Score: 32
***


Incense by Country

Wednesday, 26 February 2025

Resins - A Journey of Discovery

 






Reviews

* = Review over five years old, so may not be reliable


Monastery Mount Athos Frankincense
Holy Great Monastery Vatopedi
Aroma Amber
 (R)
Dec 2020 - Score: 38
   

NKlaus Drei Konige (Three Kings) resin (R)
Oct 2023 - Score: 37
   

Pheonix Import (Mani Bhadra)
Frankincense Resin
 (R)
Aug 2019 - Score: 35
  

Goloka Church Mix Resin Incense (R)
Oct 2023 - Score: 35 
   

Phoenix Import (Mani Bhadra)
Kamasutra Resin
 (R)
Apr 2019 - Score: 32 
  

"Amber" Frankincense from Yemen (R)
Feb 2025 - Score: 32


Cenacle Mount Athos Cypress Tree (R)
Sept 2021 - Score: 32
   

Cleopatra Dragon Blood resin (R)
March 2019 - Score: 30↑*
  

Phoenix Import (Mani Bhadra)
Egyptian Musk Resin
 (R)
Apr 2019 - Score: 30* 
   

Cenacle Qualitätsweihrauch Weihrauch fein (R)
Dec 2020 - Score: 30
   

Prinknash Incense: Abbey blend (R)
Mar 2019 - Score: 29*
   

June 2018 - Score: 27
   

The Scenter Tree Resin Myrrh: (R)
Sept 2021 - Score: 25= 
   

The Scenter Tree Resin Frankincense (R)
July 2017 - Score: 19* 
  

April 2019 - Score: 15* 
   

Dec 2022 - Score: 12
   


Reviews: 16
Top score: 38
Bottom score: 12
Average: 29

Conclusion: 


***


Amber

HEM Opium cones

 


HEM have acquired a somewhat negative reputation among some Westerners. But as far as perfumed incense goes, HEM are OK. Not great, but not bad either. There are some scents which I like less than others, and there are few HEM perfumed incenses that really rock my world (though I do still enjoy HEM Frankincense-Myrrh after repeat visits), but on the whole they make decent everyday perfumed incense at a fair price (and some pretty decent masala incense).  We tend to buy job lots of HEM cones off Amazon or eBay, and use them as low cost room fresheners in the toilet. We don't use them for aromatherapy or meditation or anything sophisticated. Like we don't use toilet paper for writing love letters. There are many incense companies who make worse than HEM. Practically all Chinese and Vietnamese and most Thailand incense is worse. The German companies, Knox and  Crottendorfer make less attractive and more expensive cones. HEM do what they do - low cost, everyday room freshener incense - and do it OK. 

This is a fair example of what they do. One of a number of incense copies of the 1977 perfume by Yves Saint Laurent. It is warm, spicy, floral, with notes of violets, carnations, black pepper, Earl Grey or Lady Grey tea, vanilla, and musk. It works. Job done. It's not original or exquisite or anything like that, but it pleasantly fragrances a room, and covers up poor odours. I don't know what proportion of DPG or DEP HEM use, but it feels less than average. Certainly less than that which is used in a number of Flora incenses, or used in the crude Pushkar incenses that have surprisingly gained some attention in the West. I am not a HEM fan by any means, but I do think the contempt that some people hold for them is seriously misplaced. Save some of that for a monolith like Zed Black.  

The music for this scent is Link Wray's "Rumble" played by Jimmy Page


Date: Feb 2025    Score: 27
***



Haria Musk Dhoop Sticks

 


Golly, this is a hearty stick. It's crude, vastly smoky, and I couldn't take it in this room for more than a few minutes. It does have a reasonably pleasant synthetic musk/sandalwood fragrance, but it is a basic musky, woody scent. There's not much to it. I smudged the house with it, and it has left a reasonably pleasant and cleansing aroma. There is a price sticker on the box of 50p. That's for 25g / 8 sticks. They can be bought today for 50p from Popat Stores

These are not bad sticks. They are what they are. A decent, heady, low cost, perfumed room freshener or smudger. Best lit and left, or used outdoors. I wouldn't recommend staying in the same room with one for long. I do think they will be brilliant for the outhouse where we feed the cats. Keep away the flies, and cover up the smell of cat meat. 


Date: Feb 2025   Score: 24
***


Dhoop


SamsaSpoon Homemade Burgundy Pitch

 


A gift from Irene of Rauchfahne, who as well as running her incense blog, also makes her own incense. SamsaSpoon is the name she uses on a Reddit incense forum, and on her emails. 

Burgundy Pitch is the resin of the Spruce tree, which has been cleaned to remove off-notes. Irene explains it here. It looks like toffee or butterscotch, and because I now have that association in my head, when I break a piece off and sniff it, it has a butterscotch toffee aroma mingled with the sweet, fresh notes of spruce, combined with some honey polish and a faint awareness of soap. It is a very attractive, slightly resinous, oily, natural scent. Very clean and uplifting. 

On the lowest heat settings on both my electric burner and my tealight burner, the resin bubbled and popped and gave off luscious wafts of spruce. Good stuff, like peat whiskey - earthy and resinous and bright. Very enjoyable. I'm not a big fan of mono-scents - I like complexity and contrast, and journeys, and stories. But this is a rather engaging scent - quite natural, quite uplifting, and somewhat interesting in itself. 


Date: Feb 2025   Score: 31
***

SamsaSpoon Homemade "Dragon"

 


A gift from Irene of Rauchfahne, who as well as running her incense blog, also makes her own incense. SamsaSpoon is the name she uses on a Reddit incense forum, and on her emails. It is how I first got to know her. She sent me this homemade incense a good while ago, along with other samples, but it got lost among my incense packages, and was only uncovered this year as I've been focused on sorting out my "legendary" backlog. As usual I know nothing about this incense, other than what is on the piece of paper in the photo which gives the name and the ingredients. I like to approach each incense blind, as a regular consumer. I may ask questions afterwards, but tend not to ask questions up front. I know from beer and wine sampling, that it is not uncommon to pick up aromas and flavours from suggestions, even when those aromas and flavours are not present. Put the idea of chocolate in your mind, and you may start to smell and taste it, even if there's nothing in your mouth. Not always, but the potential is there. Having had my initial experience, I'm really happy then to discuss it with others, and to read other reviews, and to note what I may have missed. And it can be fun to go back and see if I can discover what others have picked up. 

Anyway. What we have here are six very cute and attractive triangle shapes. They are titchy, with one side coated in gold. They look like some kind of exotic  hors d'oeuvre or mini dessert. There is a gentle, subtle aroma on the pieces - earthy, herbal, somewhat savoury, inclining to curry. Resinous notes, some wood. Quite fresh and uplifting. I'm quite happy to sniff some more. I like incense that reveals something of its true sense before the burn. 

I put one piece in my electric burner on a gentle heat, then leave the room to find a new tealight for my candle burner. When I return there is a soft, pleasant aroma of cumin - woody, spicy, some aniseed, and touches of warm maple syrup. The aroma on the candle burner is similar, though more herbal. There is no smoke from either burner. When I lowered the incense on the candle burner enough to produce smoke, the scent became acrid, so I raised it again. The scent from the electric burner, as with the previous SamsaSpoon incense, Nerikoh Night Leaves, started to become a little muddled and muggy, a little like old, damp clothes, while the scent from the candle burner remained fresh and delicious, with sweet, spicy, milk-pudding notes developing. I'm pleased with the sweet notes. The cumin scent was OK, but not really what I want from an incense. I like food and cooking scents, but as food or cooking scents. I kinda want my incense to offer me something else, something more. 

Copal Oro, one of the ingredients, is a tree resin, which some sources call the "frankincense of America". It can come from several trees, such as copaifera officinalis, to produce a resin or oil with various uses. I have reviewed several incenses with copal - New Age Black CopalSoul Sticks Aztec Aromas Copal, and Native-Spirit Copal. I have found them all attractive. The "Oro" I assume to be "Gold". I picked up the cedarwood, and the dragon's blood, though I'm unsure about the other ingredients. Calamus root has a spicy, cinnamon note, which is probably where I got the sweet, spicy milk-pudding notes. Dragonwood is given by Irene as an alternative name for juniperus chinensis - the Chinese juniper. Galangal is related to ginger. Tragacanth is a tree gum, and I assume was used as a binder. So, it appears the ingredients are largely woody and spicy. They work well together - there was no clash. The result is a clean and vibrant fragrance which is woody and spicy. 

I enjoyed it. And I liked looking up the ingredients, as some of them I wasn't aware of. For my own taste, I would have liked there to be more strength or impact or presence in the fragrance. And either more depth in the wood, or more sweetness. Or both. I found it more interesting and intriguing than delightful. But I did enjoy it. And I found the presentation of the incense in the gold coloured mini-triangles to be very cute and attractive.  Irene has posted the recipe here


Date: Feb 2025   Score: 26 
***


Loose and home-made incense

 


I'm gathering here all the loose and/or home-made incense reviews I have done. These are small operations who sell or gift their hand made incense via friends or Etsy or Facebook or forums or word of mouth. I find a direct connection between this form of incense and the original incenses made for thousands of years. Often these makers will research into ancient ways of making incense and share that research and their recipes with each other. When they sell they may charge mostly to cover costs rather than to make a profit. These are generally non-commercial operations. And they can be the most interesting and authentic incenses available. 


Reviews

* = Review over 5 years old so may not be reliable


SamsaSpoon
Homemade Swiss Stone Pine
 (D)
Oct 2023 - Score: 50↑ 


SamsaSpoon
Homemade Indian Frankincense & Cardamom
 (D)
April 2023 - Score: 42 
  

Underworld Apothecary Djinn Incense (L)
Dec 2020 - Score: 38 
   

    
Feb 2025 - Score: 31


SamsaSpoon Homemade Nerikoh Night Leaves 
Feb 2025 - Score: 30
  

   
SamsaSpoon Homemade "Dragon" 
Feb 2025 - Score: 26  


Kemet Design Hathor Incense (L)
July 2017 - Score: 19*
 

Kemet Design Kyphi Incense (L)
July 2017 - Score: 18* 
  

Kemet Design Bast Incense (L)
July 2017 - Score:  15*
  


Reviews: 9
Top score: 50
Bottom score: 15
Average: 

Conclusion: I thought I'd reviewed more than this. I know I've burned more than this. This is an interesting area of incense, and one I want to explore a bit more. 

***